Rating: 2/5
Genre: Sci-Fi/Action
The lead pair, the mega bucks, the first trailer, record number of showings, the 3D format, the SFX, Akon, Thalaivar’s guest appearance, and SRK’s marketing blitz must all add to the hype and curiosity. But the same potpourri is a recipe for failure when not cooked right. The plot written by Anubhav Sinha is about victory of good over evil. Nerdy Shekhar Subramaniam (SRK) is a video game designer based in London with wife Sonia (Kareena Kapoor) and son Prateek (Master Armaan), who does not think highly of his father. So Shekhar’s idea to impress his son is to develop a new video game (a la Kinect). The bad character from the game Ra.One wants to avenge losing (in the game) to Prateek playing G.One aka Good One, in the game. Things turn topsy-turvy when both characters jump out of the video game with Ra.One (Arjun Rampal) hounding Prateek, and G.One (SRK) playing protector.
PERFORMANCES:
As
Shekhar, SRK is not commendable. South Indian accent and mannerisms is
not SRK’s cup of tea and must strongly be advised against repeating it.
The wig doesn’t help either. Although Shekhar’s chemistry with Sonia is
dry, his relationship with Prateek is very well portrayed. As G.One,
SRK is classier, younger, muscular and actually looks like a superhero.
G.One emoting, being an automaton and especially after an ‘emotion mere syntax mein nahi hai’,
is implausible and is clearly a scripting error. The best part about
G.One is his athletic vibe, and it is refreshing to watch SRK perform
stunts. VFX is just a tool, but the ropes are tied to a real person and
G.One does so much more than just punch the bad guy. Kareena as Sonia
is eye candy chammak challo and looked too young to play soccer
mom. Kareena shares great chemistry with G.One. Eh?! OK so I have to
fizzle it out for you to let some logic in. Shekhar dies, and so.
Arjun
Rampal as Ra.One has limited appeal. His chiseled look, his suit, his
stunts are greatly in tune with sci-fi villains of today. Although
Shekhar’s villain is intended to be stronger than the hero, Arjun’s
screentime is low, and as Ra.One does not induce fear and/or
excitement. If anything, Arjun’s action is commendable in the climax.
Master Armaan (yep it’s not a girl) plays tween Prateek, who is geeky
enough to read video game program code(!). Prateek starts to respect
his father only after his untimely death, and by hanging out with
G.One. His role was etched to highlight the relationship between a
father and son, and Prateek does a decent job.
DIRECTION, SCREENPLAY & CINEMATOGRAPHY:
Being
able to handle a bunch of weighty elements called out in the beginning
of the review takes a lot of spunk. Moreso for the film producer to
hand over the reins to a Director whose filmography comprised 2 semi
sci-fi flicks that were duds. A bold decision to cast Anubhav Sinha as Director backfires
in all aspects, who has crumbled unable to use brand SRK and other
valuable resources to narrate what could have otherwise been a superb
story. The story is flawed, its not stressed enough how characters come
out of and go back into the video game; how Ra.One is interested in
fighting the player and not G.One; how Kareena is able to easily cope
with Shekhar’s death and is able to move on and develops feelings for
G.One; how G.One is able to emote; the list is virtually endless. Yes
it’s a superhero flick with nearly no holds barred, but logic and flow
helps enhance viewing experience. G.One shows up right before the
intermission and he’s only there to protect Prateek and Sonia. VFX is
used in controlled proportions and there are very specific instances
where it is commendable. Sequences that could be awe inspiring are
dampened due to westerlies like T2, Spiderman, Iron Man, etc.
Apart from the loose plot, the screenplay by Anubhav Sinha, Kanika Dhillon, Mushtaq
Sheikh, and David Benullo is a complete let down. Once the expectation is established that one solid fight between G.One and Ra.One is
mandatory, scenes in the interim are jumbled up without any definitive
meaning and probably with a sole focus to showcase VFX expertise where
possible. It would have really worked in the film's favour should G.One do more superhero than just talk. The action in general is limited and the train scene is
stretched beyond need. During the initial squabble between G.One and
Ra.One, there is no reason why they would both throw cars up in the
air, which don’t hurt either. There's some unwanted comedy like G.One
catching a bullet fired at him, up his nostril beating Dharamji's act, but still! Cinematography by
Nicola Pecorini and V. Manikandan is commendable and all characters
look their best. Used in coordination with VFX, this film is definitely
a breakthrough in homebred Indian sci-fi cinema. Specially in the
action sequences, the bike crashing, the bus accident, the train
sequence, the collapse of the terminus etc are good examples. Editing by Sanjay Sharma and Martin Walsh is
what’s the word, ah yes, shitty. There is a lot of chaff that was
included purely to thrill certain audience pockets (read children), but
the content is simply outweighed by poor chaperoning.
MUSIC:
It’s
a commonly observed relation in Hindi cinema that good movies tend to
have good music. Vishal – Shekhar’s music hasn’t caught on, except a
couple of songs – Chammak Challo and Dildara. Of
course the music wasn’t intended to propel the story, but it doesn’t
work as a great departure from the bad screenplay either. Background
score by the same duo with contribution from the Prague
Philharmonic Orchestra is catchy and does add excitement to those few
scenes where G.One does spring into action action.
WHY 2/5:
The good: A
futuristic concept although not stitched together correctly. SRK and
Kareena Kapoor. The VFX. The background score.
Potential for part 2. Red Chillies’ production values.
The bad: Direction. Screenplay. Editing. Much hard work in the wrong areas.
The bad: Direction. Screenplay. Editing. Much hard work in the wrong areas.
No comments: